by Emeritus Professor, Adrian Beck

Introduction

In the ongoing discussions around the growing importance of online retailing, particularly because of the Pandemic, it is easy to forget that the vast majority of retail transactions and sales still take place in physical retail stores – the death of ‘bricks and mortar’ retailing is a tale that has often been told but for the most part remains largely untrue. Indeed, for some retailers, their physical stores are being seen as a vital component in their capability to deliver ‘omni channel’ retailing – an amalgam of both in-person and online shopping options for the consumer.

As such, the risk of loss from retail stores, both malicious and non-malicious, remains a considerable and ongoing concern for loss prevention teams. Trying to mitigate this problem, especially theft by ‘non-paying guests’ as some have described them, has been the focus of attention for the loss prevention industry pretty much since the first retail stores opened their doors. As we discussed in an earlier blog, this risk can change because of business choices – introducing open display and self-scan checkouts has elevated the risk but at the same time has brought economic benefits as well in terms of increased sales and reduced costs. The key is striking a delicate balance between selling and security – ensuring that improvements in profitability are not wiped out by the consequences of elevated levels of risk.

Understanding the Decision to Steal

The Loss Prevention industry is not short of so called ‘solutions’ to fix the problem of retail theft; open any industry magazine or visit a vendor exhibition hall at a conference and you will be presented with a myriad of options, including a multitude of tags, video technologies, safer cases, loop alarms, smart shelves, locking cart wheels, sensors, etc to name but a few. Fundamental to any of these approaches is having a basic understanding of the motivations and methods of those who are aiming to carry out retail theft – understanding the ‘why’ and the ‘how’ can help retailers develop more effective responses to the problem.

Work by criminologists has helped to develop greater understanding of these issues, not least the degree to which most thieves are ‘rational’ acters – they in effect carry out a risk assessment driven by four key factors. These are: the perceived risk (how likely is it that I will be caught?); the relative ease with which the offence can be committed (how easy is it for me to do this?); the benefit of undertaking the offence (what will I get from doing this and is it worth it?); and the likely consequences if they were to be caught (what will happen to me if they catch me?). If they decide that the risk is low, that it is easy to do, well worth the effort and even if they were to be caught the consequences would be low, then they are highly likely to go ahead and offend. Of these factors, it has been found that the first (the risk of being caught) is the most important in an offenders’ decision-making process, while consequential punishment is regarded as the least important.

The Amplification of Risk

If the risk of being caught is the most important determinant (remember this is not necessarily the case for all offenders, especially those that are impaired by stimulants), then an important approach retailers can adopt is trying to amplify the degree to which would-be thieves believe they will be caught. This is a highly preferable approach to adopt as it is focussed upon deterring crime rather than trying to detect and respond to it. Of course, for this to be successful, the offender must first recognise the approach/intervention, and secondly, understand how it will increase the risk of being caught. For the most part, retailer strategies to achieve this goal can be divided into four main types: technologies, people, processes, and design. For the remainder of this blog, we will just focus upon the way in which design can be used to amplify risk, although the other approaches will be addressed in future articles.

Amplifying Risk Through Store Design

The way in which the design of buildings and spaces can have an impact on offending has a long track record, particularly in urban settings where it is known as Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED): ‘CPTED is an environment-behavior theory and methodology based on the proposition that enlightened architecture and site design deters criminal behavior and reduces fear of crime’. More specifically, studies have been undertaken on the retail environment looking at how it can be changed to elevate the perception of risk in would-be offenders. This work has been neatly summarized into the following areas by Carmel-Gilfilen (more information can be found in this ECR Retail Loss report):

  • Natural access control: Limits entry into a facility or space through built and natural obstacles. Examples include locks, cables, cases and security guards.
  • Natural surveillance: Enhances the capability of the occupant and observers in a facility to see what is happening around them without special action. Examples include the placement of employees, products and physical features, aisles with long lines of sight and monitoring systems like CCTV.
  • Natural territorial reinforcement: Establishes territories within a store to create a sense of ownership over the area. This increases the vigilance of users, by sending the message that trespassers will be identified. Examples include countertops, flooring, ceiling and lighting designations.
  • Maintenance: Incorporates strategies to keep spaces looking well cared for and crime-free. Maintaining elements such as lighting, paint, signage and aisles communicates to customers that management is responsible for upkeep.
  • Legitimate activity support: Promotes allowing users to engage in activities supported by the space by encouraging them to make claim to the space.

Making Offenders Think Twice

When retail losses start to escalate, it is often easy just to reach for the latest technological panacea currently on offer – the latest and greatest loss prevention widget. But history suggests that claimed successes can often be a chimera. Understanding the motivations and methods of offenders is an important step in developing interventions that are more likely to have a longer shelf life. In addition, it is easy to forget the powerful role the design of a retail environment can play in both facilitating crime and helping to control it. Getting to grips with how it can help to Amplify Risk should be viewed as an important component in any retailers’ loss prevention toolbox.